Last week, the Executive Director of the National Service Secretariat, (NSS) Michael Kpessa Whyte, commissioned 210 national service personnel who will be working as traffic wardens for the next one year.
The plan I’m told is to deploy as many as 1000 graduates under something that the NSS calls Urban Traffic Management module.
Under this module, Kpessa Whyte and the NSS intend to “revive the spirit of patriotism and love among the youth.”
This plan to achieve this magnificent feat, he said, was hatched because: “we have had in recent times, huge traffic congestion and we thought that the large numbers of our youth coming out of the tertiary institutions who are now going to traverse into the world of work are a pool of resource that could be used to ensure that we can bring some order, reduce the congestion on our roads and ensure that Ghanaian workers and commuters who are going to work have a hassle free morning and afternoon when they close from work.
This is also to revive the spirit of patriotism and love for country in our youth.”
The depths politicians will go to justify the unjustifiable is astounding. There are smarter and easier ways to revive patriotism and love for our country, Mr. Kpessa Whyte’s plan is not one of them. It’s flawed. It is a complete and a criminal waste of human resources.
A World Bank study says “university education provides the high-level skills and the training necessary for every labor market. It is these trained individuals who develop the capacity and analytical skills that drive local economies, support civil society, teach children, lead effective governments, and make important decisions which affect entire societies.”
Even with our semi-broken education system, these are some of our best brains, they should spend their year of serving Ghana transforming lives, not huddling on junctions like some people from a certain Police Visibility team.
There are 33, 000 teaching vacancies in the education sector. Most of these are presently filled by pupil teachers. There are about 50,000 vacancies in the district assemblies across the nation, these are spots that must be filled by trained and educated personnel.
I mean, what’s the sense in deploying graduates to direct traffic when they can work to improve the literacy rate in rural Ghana? Or work in district assemblies? Or serve as support staff in the health sector?
I’m in no way demeaning the traffic warden’s job. But there is a pool of unemployed, uneducated and untrained youth already doing this work in many communities, wouldn’t their love for Ghana be revived if they’re actually employed to do what they do for a few coins daily? We would be reducing unemployment among that group of the population.
And really, is this the solution to reducing the huge traffic congestion? It is interesting to note that Kpessa Whyte is championing this absurd module. Mr. Whyte, my digging has shown has a Ph.D. in Public Policy Management. He used to tout his competence in diagnosing the problem of the Ghanaian which he variously referred to as “Navigating Inefficiencies ” where he argues that instead of African governments developing and implementing policies to solve structural issues, they resort to short-term solutions which force citizens to navigate inefficiencies daily?
Example, instead of the government ensuring telecom companies provide quality service, they create the porting system knowing full well that porting won’t solve the problem.
So I wonder what possessed him to decide that the best way to use higher education graduates is for them to direct traffic. Or how now sincerely believe that absence of traffic wardens is the cause of the congestion on our roads?
Isn’t it because of a lack of a proper, safe and efficient public transportation system?? Isn’t because we do not have enough roads and existing roads are in a terrible state? Isn’t because broken down vehicles are allowed to sit at intersections of the road for hours and days?
Isn’t because road users have to compete with animals and jaywalkers? Isn’t it because in the mornings, everyone who has a car has to head to the city center? Isn’t it because of the poor maintenance of traffic lights?
What in the world made someone with a Ph.D. in public policy management decide that directing traffic is a job for the graduate at this stage of our development?
It’s beyond puzzling because Mr. Kpessa Whyte once mocked the Kufuor government’s Youth in Driving module under the NYEP saying it was a waste of human resources.
I agree with him governments must tackle structural problems with well-thought-out policies. Sadly, this Urban Traffic Management Module is not one of those, and it should be scrapped immediately.
I will not join the hoards of people on facebook who dismissed this post with a flippant statement of “Ghanaians complain too much” I think it is fair to constantly find fault with things that are broken and have never been fixed. In the same breath, I hope we can finally, once and for all, find a solution to put this NSS debate to bed. Everything must be covered, for instance, why are the only people required to show their patriotism by joining the scheme, the 5% of people who actually made it to tertiary education. It almost becomes a penalty for seeking a Bachelors and essentially undermines the professed agenda of the NSS. How does working for a private sector company (who may or may not be enjoy tax rebates) for less money than the job is actually worth, prove your patriotism or love for country? Does the NSS build personalities who will be able to make a strong contribution to society? If so, how? There are so many questions to be answered, and I’m trying to answer them in a post at journeylearnspeak.blogspot.com or follow me @thebellower to have it straight to your TL when published. 🙂
Always on point Nana. Just another proof that “book smart” and “street smart” are too different things. The mind is certainly a terrible thing to waste.